Ask the Expert: Diagnosis and Surgery

Brain Tumour Diagnosis and Treatment: A View from a Neurosurgeon

Brain tumours are usually identified from a Computed Tomography (CT) or Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) brain scan. When people present with a new diagnosis of a brain tumour, a neurosurgeon typically starts with questions about the reason why the CT or MRI scan was performed in the first place. Sometimes, a scan may have been done for reasons that are unrelated to the tumour that is identified, such as a minor head injury. More commonly, symptoms like a seizure, severe headaches or complaints concerning loss of neurological function (e.g. speech or motor function), often in combination with evidence of an abnormality during a neurological examination, will have led to the CT or MRI scan. This information (the history of symptoms, the neurological exam and the scan) provides the background essential to help guide potential further testing, treatment options and timelines for possible surgery. Physicians from surgical, medical and radiation neuro-oncology can then collaborate with each other on a daily basis to ensure treatments plans are comprehensive for every patient.

CT and MRI have revolutionized the identification and treatment of patients with brain tumours, which essentially provide the equivalent of brain pictures. Even more significant is the ability of the CT and MRI scan to not just identify that a brain tumour exists, but to establish the location and size of the mass and frequently identify the specific type of tumour.

It’s important to remember that MRI has only been available for regular patient care in the last 25 years. While a definitive diagnosis of the type of brain tumour typically requires the microscopic evaluation of a sample of the brain tumour, MRI advancements have significantly improved our ability to predict the suspected tumour type and to determine the brain anatomy and functions affected by the tumour. Although years from clinical use, research into the possible use of MRI and nanotechnology in combination will likely reach a point where a specific diagnosis and a molecular profile of a brain tumour will be determined without a surgical biopsy.

What then is the role for surgery when a person has a new diagnosis of a brain tumour?
As brain imaging has become more widely used, neuro-oncologists have worked to better understand what happens to treated and untreated patients with suspected low-grade (slow-growing) tumours to determine what the best options are. There will be times when a neurosurgeon will recommend against immediate surgery in favour of what is referred to as ‘surveillance imaging.’ This non-surgical approach is undertaken when the tumour type is obvious and when the natural history (our understanding of how the tumour ‘behaves’) is expected to be favourable. In other words, surgery may not be the ideal first choice for some patients with a brain tumour.

However, for some patients, surgery may be recommended to:

  • Provide a definite pathological diagnosis
  • Provide relief from the ‘mass effect’ produced by the tumour (relieve compression on nearby brain structures and reduce high brain pressure)
  • Provide relief from tumour hormone production (e.g. certain pituitary tumours)
  • Provide a surgical ‘cure’ if possible (applicable only for certain tumours)
  • Remove as much of a tumour as possible to optimize further treatment with radiation and/or chemotherapy

The safety and outcomes associated with surgical treatment for a patient with a brain tumour have improved significantly over the past 20 years. Some of the enhancements in surgical care that have permitted these better patient outcomes include:

  • Improvements in MRI and the ability to use this information to plan surgical approaches with precision, or repeat an MRI during an operation
  • Improvements in microsurgical techniques, endoscopic and keyhole surgery to minimize surgical trauma
  • Improvements in neuro-anesthesia to enhance safety and provide improved brain protection during an operation
  • Improved ability to do awake operations when it is necessary to have precise identification of vital brain structures responsible for functions, such as speech or limb movement, so that they can be preserved during surgery

Finally, while surgical care for patients with a brain tumour has improved significantly during the past two decades, substantial advancements have also been made in non-surgical treatment: chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Research into new diagnostic and treatment methods is very active and we should anticipate important developments during the next 10 years to further improve outcomes for people with brain tumours.

You can download this information as a Brain Tumour Foundation of Canada Information Sheet (pdf).
A special thank you to Dr. Mark Hamilton for taking the time to provide this Ask the Expert.

Dr. Hamilton is a professor of neurosurgery and the Director of Neurosurgical Oncology and the Adult Hydrocephalus Program in the Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Clinical Neurosciences at the University of Calgary. He graduated in medicine from McGill University in Montreal in 1983. After medical school, he pursued postgraduate training in neurosurgery at the University of Calgary. Dr. Hamilton followed this with a year of cerebrovascular laboratory research at the University of Calgary and an additional 18 months of fellowship training in cerebrovascular neurosurgery, skull base surgery and pediatric neurosurgery at the Barrow Neurological Institute in Phoenix, Arizona. He returned to Calgary in 1994 and was Head, Division of Pediatric Neurosurgery from 2002-2011. Dr. Hamilton was the president of the Canadian Neurosurgical Society from 2004 to 2006, a member of the Board of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons those same years, and was the president of the Canadian Neurological Sciences Federation from 2005 to 2007.

 Return to all Information Sheets

Share This

Featured Story

Kate's Mum's Story

"May 2006 is a month I will never forget. That was the moment that everything became before the cancer, and after the cancer. It was a mark in time that would forever change my family"... Read more about Kate's Mum's story from her diagnosis of glioblastoma in 2006 and how Mum has beaten the odds to still be here today.

Learn more


Roy and the Gamma Knife – A Happy Tale

I had headaches, almost daily, for 10 years or more. It was a rare day if I did not have a headache. I used to joke that I should own...

Learn more

Courtney’s Story of Stability

Stability. It’s a strange concept when you have what it known to be a progressive, life long illness. You hear the words, “Your tumour...

Learn more

Upcoming Events

  • 24/Jul/2018: Groupe de soutien virtuel: Un groupe de soutien virtuel pour personnes touchées par une tumeur... Learn more >
  • 25/Jul/2018: Toronto Support Group: Meets at Wellspring Westerkirk House at Sunnybrook, Toronto, ON... Learn more >
  • 29/Jul/2018: 11th Annual Black Diamond Car Show Presented by Thumbs Up: Black Diamond, AB... Learn more >
  • 02/Aug/2018: Ajax Support Group: Meets at St. Paul's United Church, 65 King's Crescent, Ajax, ON... Learn more >
View All Events >
Thank you to the donors whose contributions make this website and all programs, services and research possible.

Copyright © 2018 Brain Tumour Foundation of Canada. Charitable Registration #BN118816339RR0001